Gaming the School Choice Mechanism
نویسندگان
چکیده
Many public school choice programs use centralized mechanisms to match students with schools in absence of market-clearing prices. Among them, the Boston mechanism is one of the most widely used. It is well-known that truth-telling may not be optimal under the Boston mechanism, which raises the concern that the mechanism may create a disadvantage to parents who do not strategize or do not strategize well. Using a data set from Beijing, this paper investigates parents' strategic behaviors under the Boston mechanism and its welfare implications. School choice is modeled as a simultaneous game with parents' preferences being private information. The paper derives restrictions on parents' behavior under various assumptions on their information and sophistication, and the model is estimated using simulated maximum likelihood. The results suggest that parents' sophistication is heterogeneous; when parents have a greater incentive to behave strategically, they pay more attention to uncertainty and strategize better. There is no robust evidence that wealthier and/or more educated parents strategize better. If the Boston mechanism is replaced by the Deferred-Acceptance mechanism under which truth-telling is always optimal, the majority of the sophisticated parents who always play a best response are worse off, and almost none of them are better off. The reform bene ts half of the naive parents who are always truth-telling under the Boston mechanism, while it also hurts about 20% of them. JEL CODE: I28 C78 C15 D81
منابع مشابه
Gaming the Boston School Choice Mechanism in Beijing
The Boston mechanism is criticized for its poor incentive and welfare performances compared to the Gale-Shapley deferred acceptance mechanism (DA). Using school choice data from Beijing, I investigate parents' behavior under the Boston mechanism, taking into account parents' possible mistakes when they strategize. Evidence shows that parents are overcautious as they play "safe" strategies too o...
متن کاملGaming New Zealand’s Emergency Department Target: How and Why Did It Vary Over Time and Between Organisations?
Background Gaming is a potentially dysfunctional consequence of performance measurement and management systems in the health sector and more generally. In 2009, the New Zealand government initiated a Shorter Stays in Emergency Department (SSED) target in which 95% of patients would be admitted, discharged or transferred from an emergency department (ED) within 6 hours. The implementation ...
متن کاملOn the Prudence of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B: Performance Measures and Effort Allocation Between Tasks
Does a performance measure which is a monotonous function of the benefit (a benefit measure) lead to a desirable allocation of effort between the tasks which create this benefit? We analyse two settings. If the mechanism designer knows the choice set of the agent, benefit measures generally do not result in the second-best effort allocation – unless restrictive assumptions about agent’s prefere...
متن کاملOnline Attentional Bias Modification Training for Adolescents with Internet Gaming Disorder
Objective: Previous research has shown that attentional bias towards game-related stimuli is a significant factor in the etiology, maintenance and severity of Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD). Therefore, interventions targeting attentional bias towards game-related stimuli, can potentially ameliorate this disorder. The aim of the present research was to examine the effectiveness of online Attenti...
متن کاملWhat Influences Chinese Adolescents’ Choice Intention between Playing Online Games and Learning? Application of Theory of Planned Behavior with Subjective Norm Manipulated as Peer Support and Parental Monitoring
This study investigated how and why Chinese adolescents choose between playing online games and doing homework, using the model of the theory of planned behavior (TPB) in which the subjective norm was manipulated as two sub-elements (peer support and parental monitoring). A total of 530 students from an elementary school and a middle school in China were asked to complete the measures assessing...
متن کامل